Published
If you are writing up a patient-reported outcome measure (PROM) validation study, the COSMIN Reporting Guideline 2.0 is the checklist journals and reviewers now expect you to follow. Published in Quality of Life Research in 2025, it replaces the 2021 version and sets out 68 items that tell you exactly what to report about how a PROM was developed, translated, and tested. This guide explains how the 68 items are organized, what changed from version 1.0, and how to pick the item sets that match your study so your manuscript reads as complete on first submission.
In Simple Words
The COSMIN Reporting Guideline 2.0 is a checklist for papers that test how well a questionnaire measures what it claims to measure. Every paper reports 31 general items (title, abstract, methods, results, discussion). Then you add one extra set of items for each measurement property you tested, such as reliability or content validity. Together the two parts cover 68 items.
What the COSMIN Reporting Guideline 2.0 Is and Who Should Use It
COSMIN stands for COnsensus-based Standards for the selection of health Measurement INstruments. The COSMIN group has produced a family of tools for the PROM field. The COSMIN Reporting Guideline 2.0 is the one aimed at authors of primary studies on measurement properties: development studies, translation and cultural adaptation studies, and psychometric validation studies of a PROM. It was written by Gagnier, de Arruda, Terwee, Mokkink and colleagues and published in July 2025 (Gagnier et al., Qual Life Res 2025;34(7):1901-1911).
The guideline answers a practical question: what must a reader see in your paper to judge whether your PROM is valid, reliable, and fit for a given use? Reviewers use the same list to spot missing detail, and systematic reviewers use the reported information to rate the quality of your study. A paper that reports every applicable item is easier to review, easier to include in a later review, and harder to reject for incomplete methods.
You should use it if your manuscript does any of the following: develops a new PROM, adapts an existing PROM to a new language or population, or tests one or more measurement properties such as internal consistency, test-retest reliability, or responsiveness. If you are instead running a systematic review of PROMs, the relevant tool is the separate COSMIN guideline for systematic reviews of PROMs, version 2.0, covered in the comparison table below.
What Changed in the COSMIN Reporting Guideline 2.0 Compared With Version 1.0
Version 1.0 appeared in 2021 (Gagnier et al., Qual Life Res 2021;30(8):2197-2218). After the field had used it, the authors found that some items were redundant and others needed clearer wording. They ran a seven-phase update that included expert feedback, a face-to-face consensus meeting, and several rounds of revision. The authors state that version 2.0 should replace version 1.0.
- General items: 15 revised or reordered, 1 new item added, giving 31 in total.
- Specific items: 15 revised or reordered, 2 new items added, giving 37 in total.
- Overall: 30 items revised or reordered and 3 new items, giving 68.
For authors the consequence is simple. If your template or checklist file came from the 2021 paper, download the 2.0 version before you start writing. The wording and order of items have shifted, so a reporting checklist filled against version 1.0 will not line up with what editors now ask to see.
How the COSMIN Reporting Guideline 2.0 Is Built: 31 General and 37 Specific Items
The guideline has two parts. The general part applies to every study and follows the order of a manuscript. The specific part is a library of item sets, one for each measurement property. You apply only the sets for the properties your study tested.
The 31 general items
| Manuscript section | Items | What it covers |
|---|---|---|
| Title | 1 | Identifying the paper as a measurement properties study |
| Abstract | 5 | A structured summary a reader can use without the full text |
| Introduction | 4 | Rationale, the PROM, and the aims of the study |
| General methods | 9 | Design, setting, participants, sample size, data collection, and analysis |
| General results | 4 | Who took part and how the data behaved |
| Discussion | 7 | Interpretation of the findings and what they mean for use of the PROM |
| Other information | 1 | Registration, funding, and similar information |
The 37 specific items
The specific items are grouped by measurement property. Each group is a short block of items that you complete only when your study assessed that property.
| Measurement property set | Items |
|---|---|
| Content validity | 6 |
| Structural validity | 3 |
| Internal consistency | 2 |
| Cross-cultural validity | 4 |
| Reliability | 6 |
| Measurement error | 6 |
| Criterion validity | 3 |
| Construct validity | 3 |
| Responsiveness | 4 |
How to Choose the Right COSMIN Reporting Guideline 2.0 Item Sets for Your Study
The decision rule is short: report all 31 general items in every study, then add the specific set for every measurement property you assessed. Count the properties you tested, not the properties you wish you had tested. A property you did not evaluate does not need its set.
Here is a worked example. A team translates a PROM into Turkish and tests it on 200 patients. They report structural validity with a confirmatory factor analysis, internal consistency with Cronbach’s alpha, and test-retest reliability on a subsample, and they describe forward and backward translation to support cross-cultural validity. Their item count is:
- 31 general items
- 3 structural validity items
- 2 internal consistency items
- 6 reliability items
- 4 cross-cultural validity items
- Total: 46 items (31 + 3 + 2 + 6 + 4)
A second team tests how a PROM changes after surgery and compares it with a clinician-rated scale. They need the 31 general items plus responsiveness (4) and construct validity (3), for 38 items in total. Writing this count into your cover letter or reporting checklist shows editors that you matched the guideline to your design rather than copying the whole list.
If the analysis section of your paper relies on factor analysis, our guide to psychometric analysis and Cronbach’s alpha and the article on item response theory cover the statistics you will be describing in the structural validity and internal consistency items.
The COSMIN Reporting Guideline 2.0 Compared With the Other COSMIN Tools
Authors often mix up the COSMIN documents. They serve different readers and different study types.
| Document | Use it when you |
|---|---|
| COSMIN Reporting Guideline 2.0 | Write up a primary study on the measurement properties of a PROM |
| Explanation and Elaboration document | Need the rationale and good reporting examples for each item |
| COSMIN guideline for systematic reviews of PROMs 2.0 | Conduct a systematic review that compares PROMs and recommends one |
| Reporting guideline version 1.0 (2021) | Only to read an older paper; version 2.0 is the one to follow |
The Explanation and Elaboration document (de Arruda et al., Qual Life Res 2025;34(7):1891-1899) is the practical companion. When an item is unclear, read its entry there before you decide how to phrase your own methods. If you are planning the review side of PROM work, our guides to writing systematic review protocols and systematic review literature analysis pair with the COSMIN review guideline.
How to Apply the COSMIN Reporting Guideline 2.0 in Six Steps
- List the properties you tested. Write them down before drafting. This list decides which specific item sets you need.
- Download the 2.0 checklist and the Explanation and Elaboration document. Keep both open while you write.
- Draft the methods first. The nine general methods items and the specific method items for each property carry most of the detail that reviewers look for: sample size reasoning, handling of missing data, statistical methods, and the thresholds you used to judge results.
- Write the results against the same items. Report the numbers for each property with their confidence intervals, in the order your methods describe them.
- Use the discussion items to interpret, not to repeat. Seven general discussion items ask you to explain what the findings mean for using the PROM, so tie each claim to a result you reported.
- Complete the checklist and submit it. Many journals ask for a completed reporting checklist with the manuscript. Record the page or line number where each item appears.
Reporting guidelines are matched to study type in the same way across medicine. If you are also writing a thesis, see how CONSORT, STROBE, PRISMA and SQUIRE map to dissertation chapters. For the figures that go with your results, our guide to clinical research graphs shows which plots suit which analyses.
What Reviewers Check Against the COSMIN Reporting Guideline 2.0
A reviewer who knows the guideline reads your paper with the item list beside it. Three questions come up first. Can I tell which measurement properties this study set out to test? Can I tell how each one was tested, in enough detail to repeat it? Can I tell what the results mean for someone who wants to use this PROM?
The first question is answered by the title, abstract, and introduction items. Name the PROM, the population, and the properties in all three places, using the same wording each time. The second is answered by the general methods items and the specific method items for each property. This is where most revision requests start, so write this part in full sentences with the analysis plan stated before the results. The third is answered by the discussion items, where you place your findings next to the intended use of the PROM and say what a clinician or researcher can and cannot conclude.
Systematic reviewers apply a second filter. When a review team later rates your study with the COSMIN review guideline, it can only score what you reported. A missing sample size rationale or an unreported missing-data approach lowers how much weight your study can carry in a recommendation, however good the underlying work was. Reporting every applicable item is therefore not only a courtesy to reviewers; it decides how your PROM is judged in later evidence syntheses.
A practical habit helps here. Before you submit, ask a colleague who did not work on the study to read only your abstract and methods and list which properties were tested and how. If their list differs from yours, an item is missing or unclear, and it is cheaper to fix it now than during revision.
Common Reporting Gaps the COSMIN Reporting Guideline 2.0 Closes
When we edit PROM validation manuscripts, the same gaps appear again and again. The guideline was built to close them.
- The properties tested are never named. The abstract says “psychometric properties were evaluated” without listing them. The guideline wants each property and the design behind it stated up front.
- Sample size has no reasoning behind it. A single number appears in the methods with no link to the analyses it must support. State the rationale for each property.
- Missing data are not described. Readers cannot tell how many responses were lost or how they were handled. Report both.
- Content validity rests on one expert review. A panel of experts and a handful of patient interviews do not by themselves establish that a translated or adapted PROM is relevant, comprehensive, and comprehensible. Describe exactly what evidence each step supplied, using the COSMIN content validity standards (Terwee et al., Qual Life Res 2018;27(5):1159-1170) as your yardstick.
- Cronbach’s alpha stands alone. Internal consistency is reported without evidence that the scale is unidimensional. Structural validity and internal consistency belong together.
- Translation papers skip the translation process. A translated PROM needs a clear account of forward and backward translation and of how the translated version was compared with the source.
- Results are reported without a standard for judging them. State the criteria you used to call a coefficient acceptable before you show the coefficient.
COSMIN Reporting Guideline 2.0: Frequently Asked Questions
What is the COSMIN Reporting Guideline 2.0?
It is a consensus-based reporting checklist for primary studies on the measurement properties of patient-reported outcome measures, published in Quality of Life Research in 2025. It lists 68 items that describe what authors should report.
How many items does the COSMIN Reporting Guideline 2.0 have?
It has 68 items: 31 general items that apply to every study and 37 specific items that apply to individual measurement properties such as reliability, content validity, and responsiveness.
Does version 2.0 replace the 2021 version?
Yes. The authors state that version 2.0 should replace version 1.0. In total, 30 items were revised or reordered and 3 new items were added.
Do I need to report all 37 specific items?
No. You report the specific items only for the measurement properties your study assessed. Every study reports the 31 general items.
Is the guideline for systematic reviews of PROMs?
No. It is for primary studies. Systematic reviews of PROMs use the separate COSMIN guideline for systematic reviews of PROMs, version 2.0.
Where can I find explanations and examples for each item?
The Explanation and Elaboration document gives the rationale and examples of good reporting for each item. The COSMIN group also lists its tools on cosmin.nl, and the guideline is indexed on the EQUATOR Network.
Free Research Tools from Editverse
- GraphPro: build publication-ready charts, 25 types, with built-in t-test, ANOVA, correlation, and chi-square p-values. Free, no signup.
- StatPro: free statistical calculators and a test-selector tool covering group comparisons, categorical outcomes, time-to-event analysis, and diagnostic accuracy.
- Flowchart Pro: generate PRISMA 2020, PRISMA-ScR, CONSORT, STROBE, STARD, MOOSE, and ARRIVE flow diagrams directly in your browser.
Professional Editing Support for a COSMIN-Ready Manuscript
A PROM validation paper has to carry a lot of methodological detail in a limited word count. Editverse editors check your manuscript against the item sets that apply to your design, tighten the methods and results, and format the paper for your target journal.
Essential
$350
Copyediting, proofreading, and journal formatting for a manuscript that’s already structurally sound. 5-7 business days.
Advanced
$550
Substantive editing, scientific language polishing, and full citation-style verification for higher-impact targets. 7-10 business days, one free revision round.
Premium
$750
Full technical editing, figures and tables review, and re-submission support for Nature, Lancet, JAMA, NEJM, and BMJ-tier journals. 90 days of unlimited revisions.
Not sure which package fits? Send us your manuscript and the journal you are targeting and we will recommend one.
Conclusion
The COSMIN Reporting Guideline 2.0 gives PROM authors a clear contract with readers: 31 general items in every paper, plus the specific sets for each property you tested, for a maximum of 68. Match the item sets to your design, write the methods against them, and keep a completed checklist ready for submission. Doing so makes your study easier to review and easier to reuse in later systematic reviews.
References
- Gagnier JJ, de Arruda GT, Terwee CB, Mokkink LB, et al. COSMIN reporting guideline for studies on measurement properties of patient-reported outcome measures: version 2.0. Qual Life Res. 2025;34(7):1901-1911. doi:10.1007/s11136-025-03950-x
- de Arruda GT, Terwee CB, Elsman EBM, Avila MA, Gagnier JJ, Mokkink LB, et al. Explanation & Elaboration document of the COSMIN Reporting Guideline 2.0 for studies on measurement properties of patient-reported outcome measures. Qual Life Res. 2025;34(7):1891-1899. doi:10.1007/s11136-025-03949-4
- Gagnier JJ, Lai J, Mokkink LB, Terwee CB. COSMIN reporting guideline for studies on measurement properties of patient-reported outcome measures. Qual Life Res. 2021;30(8):2197-2218. doi:10.1007/s11136-021-02822-4
- Mokkink LB, Elsman EBM, Terwee CB. COSMIN guideline for systematic reviews of patient-reported outcome measures version 2.0. Qual Life Res. 2024. doi:10.1007/s11136-024-03761-6
- Terwee CB, Prinsen CAC, Chiarotto A, Westerman MJ, Patrick DL, Alonso J, et al. COSMIN methodology for evaluating the content validity of patient-reported outcome measures: a Delphi study. Qual Life Res. 2018;27(5):1159-1170. doi:10.1007/s11136-018-1829-0
