High Reliability Healthcare: How to Build a Culture of Safety

“The only way to do great work is to love what you do.” – Steve Jobs

In healthcare, making patients safe is now a top priority. Steve Jobs once said loving your work is key to greatness. This is true for healthcare groups aiming for a culture of high reliability.

Safe patient care has roots in Hippocrates’ “first, do no harm” from over 2,000 years ago. But it wasn’t until the 1990s that it became a major focus. The 1999 To Err Is Human report by the Institute of Medicine marked a turning point. Since then, patient safety has grown into a complex field.

Building a strong safety culture is essential for reliable patient care. It should be the first step for any healthcare organization.

Key Takeaways

• Creating a high reliability organization (HRO) in healthcare means aiming for zero harm and effective care.
• Starting to use high reliability concepts can begin with leaders at all levels working to improve safety.
• Five key principles of an HRO include respecting expertise, avoiding oversimplification, being sensitive to operations, committing to resilience, and focusing on failure.
• Open communication and actively finding and fixing problems are crucial for a culture of high reliability.
• Getting feedback, analyzing data, and being committed to resilience help make healthcare more reliable.

Embolden Your Safety Culture Using a Human Experience (HX) Lens

Being safe isn’t enough. Patients and employees must feel safe too. Their feelings of safety greatly affect how likely they are to recommend a healthcare place. By focusing on the human experience (HX), you can build a stronger safety culture. This improves both patient experience and employee experience.

Improving Patient Outcomes While Strengthening Your Workforce

Better employee engagement means a stronger culture of safety. This leads to better safety results. Empowered workers are key to a culture that aims for zero harm. This is crucial for keeping and supporting employees.

Environmental Cues and Clear Communication Foster Perceptions of Safety

Seeing people clean or smelling cleaning products can make places feel safe. Clear communication and teamwork also play a big role. These factors are vital because they affect how safe patients and employees feel. This feeling is closely linked to how likely they are to recommend a healthcare place.

“Safety role ambiguity, safety role conflict, and interpersonal safety conflict had negative effects on workers’ safety performance according to a study on 335 construction workers in China.”

By keeping a strong safety culture and focusing on the human experience, you can better patient outcomes. This also strengthens your workforce and makes your organization more resilient.

Better Employee Engagement Leads to a Stronger Culture of Safety

To build a safe culture in healthcare, all team members must be involved and empowered. When employees feel they have a say, they’re more likely to speak up about safety issues. This helps create a safer work environment in the short and long term.

Studies link employee engagement to better patient safety. Engaged healthcare workers tend to have a strong safety culture. On the other hand, disengaged workers struggle with safety. This shows how crucial it is to keep employees engaged and empowered.

• Highly engaged employees score at the upper end of the Culture of Safety distribution (98th to 99th percentile) for Pride and Reputation items, while the least engaged score at the first percentile rank.
• Respondents in the top quartile of engagement score between the 97th and 99th percentile rank for Prevention & Reporting items, while those in the bottom quartile perform at the first or second rank.
• Employees in the top engagement quartile have top percentile ranks for Resources & Teamwork items (94th to 97th percentile), while those in the bottom quartile perform poorly (1st to 3rd percentile).

By fostering a culture of employee engagement, healthcare organizations can make their teams more vigilant and proactive. This leads to better patient care and a stronger safety culture. It also shows the organization’s dedication to safety.

“A positive safety culture in healthcare strongly correlates with higher performance in both employee engagement and inclusion.”

It’s important to regularly check in with the workforce. This helps update important metrics and address any issues quickly. By focusing on employee engagement, healthcare organizations can strengthen their safety culture. This benefits both patients and employees.

Empowered and Resilient Workers Champion Patient and Workforce Safety

Empowered and resilient employees are key to a healthcare organization’s goal of zero harm. By creating a supportive culture, you can turn your team into safety champions. This benefits both patients and employees.

The Pursuit of Zero Harm Supports Patients and Retains Employees

The healthcare world faces many challenges in keeping safety efforts going. “Project fatigue” from dealing with many issues is a big problem. Yet, striving for zero harm is crucial. It helps keep patients safe and keeps your team happy and engaged.

• Hospitals and health systems find it hard to be excellent in every department. This affects millions of patients each year with infections, medication errors, and other preventable issues.
• Errors when moving patients between care settings harm many. Wrong surgeries happen up to 50 times a week in the U.S.
• Sadly, about 99,000 Americans die each year from infections in hospitals. Hand hygiene rates are only 40%.

Empowering your team to be safety champions is key. It helps reach the goal of zero harm. This improves patient care and keeps your team happy and loyal. High-reliability organizations in other fields, like aviation and nuclear power, show us it’s possible.

“Empowered and resilient employees are the backbone of a healthcare organization’s pursuit of zero harm.”

Safety: A Fundamental Need in Healthcare Organizations

In healthcare, the rule “First, do no harm” shows how vital patient and employee safety is. This rule matches Maslow’s hierarchy of needs, where safety is the base. It’s the most basic need for survival.

Healthcare organizations must focus on safety. Their main goal is to help people get better and stay healthy.

Research shows big differences in how people see safety culture in healthcare. Nurses often say they don’t feel safe to make mistakes without fear of blame. This shows a big challenge in making a safe work environment.

Measuring safety culture is done through surveys like AHRQ’s Surveys on Patient Safety Culture™ (SOPS®). These surveys help healthcare teams see how safe their work area is.

Poor safety culture can lead to more mistakes in healthcare. Training teams to work together and having leaders walk around to check on things can help. A focus on fixing systems, not just blaming people, is becoming more common in healthcare.

Even within the same place, people might see safety differently. This can make it hard to improve safety culture and cut down on mistakes. Groups like the National Quality Forum and the Leapfrog Group make sure safety is checked regularly.

“The commitment of management to safety is the most relevant factor in establishing a safe working environment for healthcare workers and for minimizing the risk of injury to patients.”

Building a strong organizational culture of safety is key for both patients and employees. By focusing on patient safety and employee safety, healthcare places can become better. They can offer top-notch care to their communities.

The Impact of COVID-19 on Safety Culture

Before COVID-19, patient safety culture was a concern. Slow progress was seen, but it was not enough. The pandemic forced healthcare to focus on fighting the virus.

This change led to more routine safety issues. Since then, safety hasn’t gotten better. Leaders and doctors now see safety as worse.

Routine Safety Performance Hasn’t Improved Since 2020

A study at Imperial College Healthcare NHS Trust in the U.S. showed worrying trends. It compared Safety Attitudes Questionnaire (SAQ) scores of different staff during the pandemic. Doctors and allied health professionals scored higher, but nurses scored lower.

Further research found that certain groups, like female nurses and those aged 40-49, scored lower. Training and support for redeployed staff, however, boosted scores. This shows that investing in employees can strengthen safety culture.

These findings show the challenges in keeping a strong safety culture during the pandemic. Leaders must prioritize safety and support their teams. They should create a culture where everyone feels safe to report concerns.

Understanding Human Experience is Key to Creating a Culture of Safety

In healthcare, patient safety and employee well-being are closely tied. An unsafe health system leads to less effective care and poor patient experience and employee experience. Patients can’t trust healthcare if they don’t feel safe. Employees can’t care for patients if they’re not cared for themselves.

Creating a culture of safety is crucial. It starts with understanding the human side of healthcare. This is the foundation for a safer environment for everyone.

Studies show that human errors are predictable. Knowing how mistakes happen can help prevent them. Organizations like Main Line Health have developed tools to prevent errors.

A positive safety culture is linked to better patient safety. The National Patient Safety Foundation says leadership support is key. Traits like transparency, accountability, and respect are essential for a safety culture.

The Joint Commission stresses the need for a positive safety culture. They have standards for patient safety programs to prevent medical errors.

“Numerous studies indicate a strong connection between a positive safety culture and enhanced patient safety in healthcare organizations.”

Understanding the human experience is key to a safer healthcare. It builds trust and empowers teams. This leads to better care and makes healthcare more reliable.

Three Overarching Strategies to Meet Safety Goals

Make Safety Visible Through Transparency and Candid Communication

Top healthcare groups know that safety is key. They make safety clear through open talks and honest sharing. Leaders must tell employees and patients about their safety plans and progress.

Being open and sharing safety data builds trust. It shows a strong safety culture. This way, leaders show they care about safety for everyone.

It’s also important to let employees speak up freely. This psychological safety lets staff share ideas. Together, they can make safer work processes.

“Effective leadership involvement at all levels is crucial for establishing a culture of safety in healthcare.”

When safety is clear and open, healthcare does better. They meet safety goals and give top-notch care.

Prioritize Employee Engagement for Better Safety Outcomes

The healthcare industry is facing big challenges. Keeping a strong safety culture is more important than ever. But, employee engagement, a key part of safety culture, has been dropping since 2018. The COVID-19 pandemic made things worse, causing a lot of burnout.

Studies show that when employees are engaged, patient safety gets better too. This is a big deal for healthcare.

Healthcare groups need to see employee engagement as part of diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI). Research shows that a positive safety culture is linked to better employee engagement and inclusion. By focusing on DEI, organizations can create a welcoming place. This boosts employee happiness and helps keep patients safe.

Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion Drives Safety Culture

Places with strong safety cultures have happier staff, fewer injuries, and less burnout. They also see better patient satisfaction and shorter stays. A strong safety culture means fewer deaths for both patients and staff.

But, the healthcare world is struggling. In 2022, 100,000 nurses left their jobs. By 2027, 610,388 nurses plan to do the same. In 2023, 25% of American medical students might choose other careers, and 58% of global students want non-patient-facing roles.

To tackle these issues, healthcare needs to focus on keeping employees happy and engaged. This could lower patient harm and make care better by up to 20% for every 25% increase in nurse job satisfaction.

There’s not much research on how to boost patient safety and employee engagement in healthcare. But, industries like nuclear power and aviation have found ways to reduce errors. Healthcare is looking into these methods to cut down on medical mistakes, which are a big problem.

“By prioritizing employee engagement and a culture of safety, healthcare organizations can not only improve patient outcomes but also retain and empower their most valuable asset – their workforce.”

Focus on Organizational Resilience to Overcome Crises

The COVID-19 pandemic has shown how crucial organizational resilience is. It’s the ability for an organization to recover from a crisis. Healthcare groups need to adopt a high reliability organizing (HRO) mindset to achieve this.

The Four Fundamentals of High Reliability Organizing

Following the four main principles of HRO can help healthcare groups build a strong safety culture. This makes them more resilient during crises:

1. Adopt the goal of zero harm – Make patient and employee safety the top priority. Aim to eliminate all preventable harm.
2. Measure harm and make harm visible – Keep track of safety metrics. This helps spot areas for betterment and promotes openness.
3. Foster a fair and just culture – Create a place where employees can report errors and near-misses without fear. This encourages a blame-free environment.
4. Practice daily check-ins for safety – Hold regular safety meetings. This keeps everyone informed, addresses concerns, and reinforces safety rules.

By adopting these HRO principles, healthcare organizations can boost their resilience. This helps them handle crises like the COVID-19 pandemic better.

“High reliability organizations (HROs) like aircraft carriers, electrical power grids, and wildland firefighting demonstrate nearly error-free performance despite potential catastrophic failures.”

high reliability organization, safety culture, error prevention

In the fast-changing world of healthcare, being reliable is key. Healthcare groups must follow the four main steps of high reliability organizing. This helps them build a strong safety culture and be more resilient.

Healthcare is always a bit unpredictable, but we can lower harm to patients and staff. By doing so, we improve care and make healthcare better for everyone.

To create a safe culture, healthcare places must focus on preventing errors. Studies show that errors often come from many factors going wrong. So, they need to use strong plans to stop these errors.

These plans should include using technology, reducing distractions, and having backup systems. They also need to use engineering controls to keep things safe.

The Cleveland Clinic uses a Just Culture decision guide to avoid blaming staff for problems. This approach builds trust and encourages honesty. It rewards staff for reporting safety issues while keeping professional standards.

This way, they avoid a culture of fear. Instead, they encourage open reporting of safety concerns.

Hartford HealthCare is working to make healthcare more reliable. They have programs like “Safety Starts with Me.” These focus on safety culture, preventing errors, and safe practices.

These programs make sure everyone knows and follows safety rules. They help deepen the commitment to safe care.

“Safety and quality must remain the primary focus for hospital leaders to prevent avoidable harm or unreliable processes.”

By following the high reliability organization model, healthcare can change its safety culture. This empowers staff and leads to better care. It also puts the well-being of patients and staff first.

Leadership Commitment is Critical for an Effective Safety Culture

Leadership’s commitment to safety is key for a safety culture in any organization. They must show their dedication through actions, like getting safety training and making safety a top priority. They should also have clear safety policies and regularly check if these policies are working.

High reliability theory, from the 1980s, helps healthcare organizations build a strong safety culture. It outlines five key principles. These principles ensure safety is always a priority in the workplace.

A report by the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ) highlights the importance of valuing expertise. Organizations should identify and empower those with the most knowledge. This way, they can share their insights and improve operations.

Safety experts in these organizations don’t oversimplify complex issues. They focus on fixing problems to prevent future risks. They also consider the bigger picture, linking safety to the organization’s overall goals.

Effective leadership focused on patient safety is vital for a culture of safety in healthcare. A strong safety culture promotes dignity, respect, and teamwork. This leads to better patient care and less burnout among staff.

“The importance of professional leadership attitudes in a High Reliability Organization is emphasized for managing potentially hazardous activities to maintain risk to people and the environment as low as reasonably achievable, thus assuring stakeholder trust.”

Leaders who promote transparency and follow up on safety reports help create a safe environment. They foster healthy relationships, open communication, and trust. These are essential for a strong safety culture in any organization.

Empower and Engage All Employees in Ongoing Vigilance

To build a strong safety culture in healthcare, all employees must be empowered and engaged. Everyone, from frontline workers to leaders, must share the responsibility for safety. This shared commitment is key to high reliability organizations (HROs) that thrive in risky environments.

Effective Communication Promotes a Safety Culture

At the core of this effort is multidirectional communication. HROs move away from top-down communication. Instead, they encourage everyone to share their insights on safety risks and improvements. This open communication makes employees feel valued, leading to better safety and resilience.

By following these principles and promoting a culture of employee engagement and communication, healthcare can stay vigilant. This helps prevent bad events and improves patient safety and care quality.

Foster Psychological Safety for Open Communication

Creating a safety culture in healthcare is key. A big part of this is making sure everyone feels safe to share their thoughts and ideas. This means they can point out problems without fear of being judged or punished.

Leaders are very important in making sure everyone can talk openly. By focusing on psychological safety, they help employees feel free to talk about safety risks. This leads to better care and fewer mistakes.

Studies show that feeling safe at work really matters for safety. One study found that when people feel safe, they see fewer safety risks. It also showed that good communication helps make a safer work environment.

“A psychologically safe culture supports adherence to policies and procedures while also promoting independent action and mindfulness among staff.”

Healthcare places that value safety and open communication create a special culture. Here, employees feel brave enough to share their concerns and learn from mistakes. This makes the place safer and better for everyone.

Adopt Principles of Highly Reliable Organizations (HROs)

To achieve top safety and quality in healthcare, look to industries known for success in risky settings. [https://www.editverse.com/avoiding-research-misconduct-guidelines-for-2024-2025/]Healthcare can learn from highly reliable organizations (HROs) like the nuclear and airline sectors. These industries have built strong safety cultures and learn from mistakes to avoid failures.

Characteristics of HROs to Incorporate

Healthcare should adopt key traits of HROs:

• Preoccupation with failure: Always watch for small problems or changes, focusing on preventing errors.
• Reluctance to simplify: Avoid simplifying complex issues and keep a detailed understanding of systems.
• Sensitivity to operations: Stay aware of ongoing activities and watch for early warning signs of trouble.
• Commitment to resilience: Be able to quickly recover from setbacks and adapt to changes.
• Deference to expertise: Give frontline staff the knowledge and skills to make decisions, not just follow orders.

By adopting these principles, healthcare can create a strong safety culture and reduce errors. This leads to better patient care and happier staff.

Integrate Continuous Process Improvement Methods

Building a safety culture starts with a systematic approach to continuous improvement. Effective change management and the Plan-Do-Study-Act (PDSA) model are key. They help healthcare organizations improve clinical processes and outcomes.

Using Lean and Six Sigma tools is also important. These tools help in measuring, testing, and implementing changes. This leads to a culture that focuses on safe and effective care.

Change Management Facilitates Continuous Improvement

The Plan-Do-Study-Act (PDSA) model is a solid framework for continuous improvement. It involves planning, action, studying, and acting to refine the next cycle. This model helps in making clear goals and understanding what changes are needed.

The Plan-Do-Study-Act (PDSA) Model for Improvement

HROs use Lean and Six Sigma tools to improve processes. Lean aims to remove waste and improve efficiency. Six Sigma focuses on reducing variation for reliable performance.

By using these tools, organizations can speak the same language of improvement. This is crucial for a unified and effective improvement culture.

“Integrating a systematic and structured approach to continuous improvement is another foundation in building a safety culture.”

Conclusion

Making healthcare safer is a big goal, but we’ve made good progress. Since 1999, we’ve cut down on mistakes and made care safer for patients. This is thanks to strong leadership, open communication, and better ways to improve care.

Studies show that a strong safety culture makes a big difference. It leads to fewer patient harms and lower hospital death rates. Also, when employees feel safe, patients are safer too.

To make healthcare safer, we need to work together. We must empower staff, be open, and always look for ways to get better. By following the ways of high-reliability organizations, leaders can make safety the main focus. This way, everyone can help make care better for all.

Source Links

• https://web.mhanet.com/media-library/high-reliability-organization-toolkit/
• https://psnet.ahrq.gov/primer/high-reliability
• https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8801703/
• https://www.academia.edu/95080238/Patient_Safety_and_Quality_An_Evidence_Based_Handbook_for_Nurses
• https://info.pressganey.com/press-ganey-blog-healthcare-experience-insights/safety-and-high-reliability-the-core-of-human-experience-healthcare
• https://info.pressganey.com/press-ganey-blog-healthcare-experience-insights/supporting-patient-safety-requires-higher-employee-engagement
• https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9384574/
• https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3790522/
• https://www.ahrq.gov/sites/default/files/wysiwyg/patient-safety/settings/hospitals/hroadvice.pdf
• https://psnet.ahrq.gov/primer/culture-safety
• https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10811440/
• https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7579589/
• https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9315290/
• https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.06.15.20129080v1.full.pdf
• https://www.mainlinehealth.org/-/media/files/pdf/basic-content/ems/culture-of-safety-error-prevention.pdf
• https://www.ecri.org/components/HRC/Pages/RiskQual21.aspx
• https://www.mgma.com/articles/advancing-a-culture-of-safety-to-deliver-highly-reliable-healthcare
• https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4710092/
• https://www.mha.org/Portals/0/Documents/MHA Keystone Center/Tools/reliability-culture-implementation-guide.pdf
• https://repository.library.northeastern.edu/files/neu:4f248p53b/fulltext.pdf
• https://www.hsrd.research.va.gov/publications/esp/high-reliability-org.pdf
• https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3388695/
• https://www.hsrd.research.va.gov/publications/esp/high-reliability-org-supplemental.pdf
• https://consultqd.clevelandclinic.org/10-leadership-mindsets-for-high-reliability-organizations
• https://hartfordhealthcare.org/patients-visitors/patients/patient-quality-safety/culture-of-safety
• https://www.assp.org/news-and-articles/how-safety-leaders-can-create-high-reliability-organizations
• https://www.jointcommission.org/-/media/tjc/newsletters/sea-57-safety-culture-and-leadership-final3.pdf
• https://www.nrc.gov/about-nrc/regulatory/enforcement/hro-sc-collins.pdf
• https://www.huronconsultinggroup.com/insights/achieving-zero-harm-high-reliability-organizations
• https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK2672/
• https://www.americandatanetwork.com/patient-safety/hro-trait-sensitivity-to-operations-key-concepts-benefits/
• https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9577937/
• https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/psychology/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2023.1164288/pdf
• https://bmchealthservres.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12913-022-08418-z
• https://www.ihi.org/sites/default/files/Federico_IsYourOrganizationHighlyReliable_HCExec_Jan2018.pdf
• https://www.ghx.com/the-healthcare-hub/hro-healthcare-guide/
• https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK214937/
• https://www.americandatanetwork.com/patient-safety/the-ultimate-guide-to-becoming-a-high-reliability-organization-free-tools-to-help-build-your-hro-and-measure-progress/
• https://oneumms.org/wp-content/uploads/High-Reliability-and-Safety-Culture-Focus-on-Leadership.pdf
• https://journalofethics.ama-assn.org/article/how-high-reliability-can-facilitate-clinical-organizational-and-public-health-responses-global/2024-02
• https://qualitysafety.bmj.com/content/31/12/867